Pushover Analysis Verification Studies
This article summarizes how the StatiCAD pushover engine and the reinforced concrete performance assessment chain were verified, and the results. Reinforced concrete example buildings exhibiting both frame and shear wall behaviour were used as test structures.
1. Verification approach
- Same model, independent solver: StatiCAD automatically transfers the pushover model (nodes, members, rigid diaphragm, masses, load pattern and the hinge capacities it has computed itself) to SAP2000; SAP2000 pushes it with its own nonlinear solver. The comparison is thus a repeatable model-to-model comparison free of manual data entry errors.
- The reference is SAP2000 V27: It was chosen as the verification reference because it is an internationally recognised, independent solver.
- The focus of the comparison is the performance point: The engineering decision is made at the demand point. Therefore the main criteria are the agreement of the displacement, base shear, hinge state distribution and building decision at the demand point. Curve peak values are a secondary indicator because of modelling differences (see Section 6).
The same comparisons can be reproduced in every project with the “Verify with SAP2000” and “Continue calculations with the SAP2000 result” options in the pushover window.
2. Modal verification
The pushover model builds columns and shear walls with their local axes from the main analysis; it takes the storey masses and the storey torsional inertia from the nodal mass distribution of the main analysis. The natural vibration periods of the model transferred to SAP2000 agree with StatiCAD within 1.3%:
| Example | StatiCAD pushover model [s] | SAP2000 [s] |
|---|---|---|
| Shear wall (T1 / T2) | 0.2946 / 0.1755 | 0.2956 / 0.1777 |
| Frame (T1 / T2 / T3) | 0.6044 / 0.5760 / 0.4486 | 0.6057 / 0.5763 / 0.4491 |
In the shear wall example, the elastic displacements at the top node are identical in the two programs (X 1.673 mm, Y 2.299 mm). The design spectrum inputs (SDS, SD1) matched exactly with the independent calculation.
3. Damage comparison at the demand point — the main verification
From the hinge state table of SAP2000, the hinge state of the step corresponding to the demand displacement is read and compared with the StatiCAD damage table:
| Run (shear wall building, EPP) | StatiCAD | SAP2000 | Yielded ends common to both programs |
|---|---|---|---|
| +X, demand u = 7.13 mm | 4 yielded ends, building: Controlled Damage | 6 yielded ends | 4 |
| −Y, demand u = 12.04 mm | 23 yielded ends, building: Controlled Damage | 22 yielded ends | 20 |
Result: At the demand point, the yielded ends of the two independent solvers are largely the same: in +X all of StatiCAD's yielded ends, in −Y 20 of the 23 ends also yielded in SAP2000. At the same node and equal displacement, the base shear ratio is 0.998–1.003 in +X and 0.999–1.002 in −Y.
4. Summary comparison of the eight direction combinations
The shear wall building values in this section and in Section 5 were obtained with an earlier version of the program: they show the agreement between the two solvers, not the current pushover behaviour of the building. The current values are in Sections 2 and 3.
In the “Continue calculations with the SAP2000 result” mode, all eight TBDY direction combinations were solved in SAP2000 and automatically tabulated with the StatiCAD results (shear wall example, EPP; u: demand roof displacement):
| Direction | StatiCAD u [mm] | StatiCAD level | SAP2000 u [mm] | SAP2000 level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| +X+0.30Y | 3.45 | KH | 3.45 | KH |
| +X−0.30Y | 3.45 | KH | 3.45 | KH |
| −X+0.30Y | 3.45 | KH | 3.45 | KH |
| −X−0.30Y | 3.45 | KH | 3.45 | KH |
| +Y+0.30X | 13.40 | SH | 13.36 | KH |
| +Y−0.30X | 13.41 | SH | 13.36 | SH |
| −Y+0.30X | 13.40 | SH | 13.22 | SH |
| −Y−0.30X | 13.39 | SH | 13.22 | SH |
- The demand displacements match exactly (X: 3.45 ↔ 3.45 mm; Y: 13.4 ↔ 13.2–13.4 mm).
- The difference in the base shears at the demand point is about 5–10% in the X direction and 3–13% in the Y direction.
- The building decision is the same in 7 of the 8 directions. The only difference (+Y+0.30X) is a borderline case where the demand falls exactly on the yield limit and is sensitive to the SAP2000 output step resolution.
5. Single-direction comparison and strain-hardening hinge option
| Run (single direction) | StatiCAD Vroof [kN] | SAP2000 Vroof [kN] | Peak ratio | Ratio at the same node, equal displacement | Point where SAP2000 stopped |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| +X, EPP | 12,286 | 11,222 | 1.095 | 0.998–1.005 | 49 mm |
| +X, strain-hardening | 13,471 | 12,343 | 1.091 | 0.974–0.992 | peak at 66 mm, then drop |
| −Y, EPP | 5,432 | 4,693 | 1.158 | 1.000–1.015 | 144 mm |
| −Y, strain-hardening | 5,739 | 5,455 | 1.052 | 0.978–1.014 | 256 mm |
Strain hardening raises the StatiCAD capacity by 5–10% (+X 9.6%; −Y 5.7%). Because the descending branch of the hinges in SAP2000 stops the analysis before StatiCAD's target, the peak/peak ratio comes out as 1.05–1.16; this is not a capacity difference. The base shear ratio at the same node and equal displacement is 1.00–1.02 in the EPP runs and 0.97–1.01 in the strain-hardening runs. The demand point comparisons are not affected by hardening.
6. Known differences
| Difference | Source | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Descending branch in SAP2000 ↔ plateau in StatiCAD | The SAP2000 hinge definition has strength-drop branches; the StatiCAD hinge (EPP or strain-hardening) has no descending branch. | The SAP2000 curve drops after peaking and in some runs stops before reaching the target. It affects the peak value ratios but not the demand point comparison. In the shear wall example SAP2000 stops at the first strength loss; the peak/peak ratio of 1.05–1.16 is due to this, and at equal displacement the ratio is 0.97–1.02. |
| Constant axial force of columns and shear walls | In both solvers the hinges are built with N = G + nQ. | It does not affect the comparison; it is a common assumption. |
| Definition of the hardening slope | The two programs define the hardening branch differently. | ±0.03 variation in the strain-hardening peak ratios. |
| SAP2000 output step resolution | SAP2000 results are recorded in a finite number of steps. | The damage reading is taken from the recorded step nearest to the demand point; it may create decision sensitivity in runs at the yield limit. |
7. Verification of multi-mode pushover
- Elastic consistency (TBDY 5.6.6.1): For each mode, the closed-form spectral displacement was compared with the finite element solution on the same stiffness matrix. In the X and Y directions the deviation was 0.0000% for all modes; the CQC combined roof displacement is the same by both routes.
- Dominant-mode pushover ↔ single-mode pushover: The first-mode pushover of the multi-mode run gave the same demand (36.82 mm) and the same building decision (Controlled Damage) as the single-mode pushover; the numbers of yielded ends differ slightly because the load patterns of the two methods differ (27 / 25).
- ± direction: In an X-symmetric building the −X multi-mode run gives the same CQC roof displacement and building decision as +X; the numbers of yielded ends at the first-mode demand point are 25 / 24.
- Short-period rule: In the short-period second X mode (T = 0.155 s), CR = 1.030 was applied automatically and the mode remained elastic as expected.
- Modal pattern comparison with SAP2000: The StatiCAD modal load patterns were transferred to SAP2000 and pushed on the same hinged model; in the elastic region the mode curves coincide within 0–1%. The ratio at the dominant-mode demand point at the same node and equal displacement is 1.081; this difference is of the same size as in the single-mode comparison of the same building (0.996–1.084), that is, it is not specific to the multi-mode method.
- IRSA (incremental response spectrum analysis): With hinge formation switched off, the IRSA core is identical to the closed form of mode combination with a deviation of 0.0000%. In twelve runs, IRSA, multi-mode and single-mode methods give demands within ±1% and the same building decisions (Controlled Damage). In full IRSA (period per piece and CR per step), the periods lengthened by hinge formation increase the demand by 11–18% (frame ±X: 43.70 / 43.45 mm; shear wall ±Y: 38.99 / 38.85 mm); the decision does not change in these buildings.
8. Beam–column joint shear check
The beam–column joint shear check of the linear assessment (TBDY 15.5.2.5, Eq. 7.11–7.13) was tested on a reinforced concrete test building with shear walls:
- The calculation of the 72 column top joints is identical to the hand calculation: Ve = max(0; 1.25·fy·As − Vkol), limit 1.0·bj·h·√fc or 1.7·bj·h·√fc. For example, for As = 339 mm², fy = 500 MPa and Vkol = 242.5 kN: Ve = 0, limit 1250 kN.
- With the real material no brittle joint occurred; the results of the 72 columns remained identical to those of the version before the check was added.
- When the reinforcement yield strength was artificially increased, 24 of the 72 joints became brittle; the column rows stated that the joint is brittle (15.5.2.5), and 24 warning lines appeared in the project checklist.
9. Pushover with the rigid end zone on (TBDY 15.4.10)
When the Rigid End Zone option in Project General Settings is on, in the pushover and IRSA model too the beam ends are taken as rigid up to the column face and the column top end as rigid by the beam depth; the hinges are at the ends of the flexible part (at the column / beam face for RZ = 1). For details see Rigid End Zone (TBDY 15.4.10). In the frame example building, for RZ = 1:
| Direction | Vmax off → RZ = 1 [kN] | First yield V off → RZ = 1 [kN] | Demand off → RZ = 1 [mm] | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| +X | 1,304 → 1,399 | 543 → 632 | 36.82 → 32.60 | Controlled Damage |
| −X | 1,309 → 1,415 | 557 → 633 | 36.82 → 32.60 | Controlled Damage |
| +Y | 1,000 → 1,090 | 309 → 414 | 35.10 → 29.23 | Controlled Damage |
| −Y | 1,003 → 1,095 | 325 → 425 | 35.10 → 29.23 | Controlled Damage |
The rigid arms stiffen the building (T1 0.6061 → 0.5350 s), the demand displacement decreases by 12–17% and the capacity increases by 7–9%. In the SAP2000 V27 comparison (the same rigid arms are transferred as end offsets), the T1 ratio for RZ = 0.5 / 1 is 0.9416 / 0.8827 in StatiCAD and 0.9424 / 0.8843 in SAP2000; the base shear ratio at the same node and equal displacement is 0.99–1.01.
10. Polygon and asymmetric column sections
The pushover model builds the moment–curvature relationship of polygon and asymmetric column sections separately for two directions from the fibre section; the moment axis is the centroid of the section. In the model built by replacing six columns of the shear wall example building with a T-shaped 100 × 65 section, for N = 445 kN the nominal moment capacities were found as Mn+ = 492.9 kNm and Mn− = 281.4 kNm; the independent fibre calculation gives 492.8 / 281.4 kNm and the curvatures are identical.
11. Overall assessment
- In the SAP2000 model-to-model comparison, at the demand point where the engineering decision is made, displacements match exactly, damage tables agree, and building decisions are the same in 7 of 8 directions; the only difference is a documented borderline case.
- In the current shear wall model, the natural vibration periods agree with SAP2000 within 1.3% and the elastic top displacements are identical; at the demand point, the base shear ratio at equal displacement is 0.998–1.003.
- At the same node and equal displacement, the base shear ratio is 1.00–1.02 in the EPP runs and 0.97–1.01 in the strain-hardening runs. Because the descending branch of the SAP2000 hinges stops the analysis before the target, the peak/peak ratio comes out as 1.05–1.16; this is not a capacity difference. The elastic model is transferred to SAP2000 exactly; each of the remaining differences has been separated out and justified.
- The elastic consistency condition of multi-mode pushover is satisfied numerically.
It is essential that all results produced by the software are checked by the responsible engineer.