Steel Structures Verification Studies
This article summarises the verification studies of the steel beam and column module. The calculation core was first developed in an independent test application using the code formulas, and then every quantity reflected in the report was compared with hand calculations. The end-to-end workflow (open file → analysis → report) and bilingual report generation were also checked. For the formulas see Theoretical Basis of Steel Design.
1. Test model
| Member | Section / material | Parameters |
|---|---|---|
| Beam | IPE A 100, S235 | Lb = 6000 mm (automatic = member length), Cb from the moment diagram, deflection K = 300 |
| Column | IPE A 100, S235 | KLx = KLy = 3000 mm (storey height, K = 1) |
IPE A 100 catalogue values: A = 880 mm², Ix = 1.41×10⁶ mm⁴, Iy = 1.31×10⁵ mm⁴, Sx = 28,800 mm³, Zx = 33,000 mm³, Zy = 7,500 mm³, Sy = 4,770 mm³, J = 7,700 mm⁴, Cw = 2.8×10⁸ mm⁶, h = 98, b = 55, tw = 3.6, tf = 4.7 mm. In this model the value E = 2.1×10⁶ kg/cm² on the material card was used as 205,940 MPa.
Using IPE A 100 as a column with KL/r = 246 is not a realistic design but a deliberate limit scenario: in a single model it tests that the elastic buckling branch, the KL/r > 200 warning and the small capacity values pass correctly through the report chain.
2. Beam verification (elastic lateral–torsional buckling region)
| Quantity | StatiCAD report | Hand calculation | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section properties | A = 8.8 cm², Ix = 141 cm⁴, Wel = 28.8 cm³, Wpl = 33.0 cm³, ry = 1.22 cm | Unit conversion of the catalogue values | Exact |
| Lp | 64 cm | 1.76·12.2·√(205940/235) = 636 mm | Exact |
| Lr | 283 cm | rts = 14.5 mm; J·c/(Sx·h0) = 0.002866; Lr = 2833 mm | Exact |
| Limit state | Elastic lateral–torsional buckling | Lb = 600 > Lr = 283 cm → elastic region | Consistent |
| Cb | 1.93 | 1.6G+Q station moments: Mmax = 0.3711, MA = 0.0469, MB = 0.2210, MC = 0.1512 kNm; 12.5·0.3711/(2.5·0.3711 + 3·0.0469 + 4·0.2210 + 3·0.1512) = 1.928 | Exact |
| Mn | 4.13 kNm | Lb/rts = 413.8; Fcr (Cb = 1) = 74.4 MPa; Mn = 1.928·74.4·28,800 = 4.132 kNm | Exact |
| Vn | 49.74 kN | 0.6·235·(98·3.6) = 49.75 kN (Cv1 = 1) | Exact |
| Deflection | f = 0.47 cm ≤ L/300 = 2.00 cm | 5/48·3670·600²/(2.1×10⁶·141) = 0.465 cm | Exact |
3. Verification of the Lb and Cb rules
In a model of IPE 300 (S235) beams (G = 1000 kg/m + Q = 500 kg/m distributed load), four different support cases were compared with an independent calculation working with the finite element station moments:
| Beam | Lb / Cb | φb·Mn (StatiCAD) | Independent calculation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 m cantilever | 3000 mm / 1.000 | 117.51 kNm | 117.51 kNm |
| 6 m secondary beam (both ends framing into the mid-spans of main beams) | 6000 mm / 1.136 | 90.65 kNm | 90.65 kNm |
| 6 m simply supported (both ends pinned) | 6000 mm / 1.136 | 90.65 kNm | 90.65 kNm |
| 6 m rigid-ended | 6000 mm / 1.157 | 92.26 kNm | 92.26 kNm |
Selection of the governing combination: When the simply supported beam is loaded with G as a point load at mid-span and Q as a distributed load, the largest moment is given by the 1.6G+Q combination (105.54 kNm, Cb = 1.260, demand/capacity ratio 1.050). The governing combination, however, is 1.2G+1.6Q (103.59 kNm, Cb = 1.229, ratio 1.057). The program and the independent calculation give the same combination and the same values; for all beams the difference is smaller than 10⁻¹² kNm.
4. Subtraction of the offset-induced artificial axial force
The models with IPE 300 beams (A, B, C) from Section 3 and a 14-beam IPE A 100 model were each solved with the offset options in Project General Settings (Offset1/Offset2 and eccentricity) on and off. The table gives the design axial force of the beam (kN) and the M–N–V ratio; the first column is the calculation in which the share is not subtracted.
| Beam | Offset on, share not subtracted | Offset on, share subtracted | Offset off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simply supported (model A) | 373.94 / 1.429 | 1.75 / 1.102 | 0 / 1.101 |
| Cantilever (model A) | 318.02 / 1.139 | 0 / 0.859 | 0 / 0.859 |
| Rigid-ended (model A) | 332.09 / 1.258 | 1.75 / 0.967 | 0 / 0.838 |
| Simply supported, carrying a secondary beam (model B) | 721.07 / 2.702 | 1.75 / 2.070 | 0 / 2.068 |
| Rigid-ended (model C) | 573.19 / 2.137 | 1.75 / 1.635 | 0 / 1.433 |
| Secondary beam (model C) | 287.68 / 1.092 | 1.34 / 0.840 | 0 / 0.839 |
| IPE A 100 model (14 beams) | 3.2–5.1 / at most 0.203 | 0.03 / at most 0.188 | 0 / at most 0.158 |
- Equation: In the simply supported beam of model A (12 segments), the ratio of the finite element segment axial force to the segment average moment is −3.9444 m⁻¹ in all 12 segments for both the G and Q load cases; with the catalogue section, ck = 53.81 × (−15) / (8356 + 53.81 × 225) = −3.9444 m⁻¹. The remaining 1.75 kN agrees with the trapezoidal-rule remainder of the 12-segment division ((2/3)/12² = 0.46%; 0.46% × 373.9 kN).
- Remaining difference: The difference between the offset-on and offset-off ratios occurs only in rigid-ended beams and only in the moment (model A: 84.81 / 74.49 kNm; model C: 152.37 / 136.17 kNm). This difference is the effect of the offset on the beam stiffness; it is not artificial. In simply supported beams and cantilevers the ratios of the two cases differ by at most 0.002.
- Unchanged: In the offset-off solutions all beam results are identical to the calculation made without subtracting the share; the column results do not change in either case.
5. Column verification (elastic flexural buckling)
| Quantity | StatiCAD report | Hand calculation | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| rx, ry | 4.00 cm, 1.22 cm | √(I/A): 40.0 mm, 12.2 mm | Exact |
| Largest KL/r | 245.9 and “KL/r>200!” warning | 3000/12.2 = 245.9 > 200 | Exact |
| Governing mode | y-axis flexural buckling | Fey = 33.6 < Fex ≈ 361 < Fez ≈ 437 MPa | Consistent |
| φcPn | 23.36 kN | Fey = 33.6 MPa; Fy/Fe = 6.99 > 2.25 → Fcr = 29.5 MPa; Pn = 25.96 kN; φcPn = 23.36 kN | Exact |
| φMny (weak axis) | 1.59 kNm | 0.9·min(235·7500; 1.6·235·4770) = 1.586 kNm | Exact |
| Interaction | Eq. 11.3b = 0.092, UYGUN | Pr/Pc = 0.024 < 0.2 → 11.3b; 0.090 with rounded values | Consistent (rounding) |
6. Steel truss and purlin members
Compression buckling in beams and the Eq. 11.3 interaction, tension in columns and the other section types (U, box, pipe, L) were tested with a steel truss and purlin model (84 steel beams, 27 posts) built on a 10 × 8 m masonry building with four walls.
| Member | StatiCAD | Hand calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| HE 100 A top chord (panel L = 1000 mm) | φcPn = 416.0 kN | λ = 1000/25.1 = 39.8 → Fcr = 0.658^(0.19)·235 MPa → 0.9·Pn ≈ 416 kN | Exact |
| IPE 120 purlin (L = 3000 mm, N = 41.1 kN compression) | φcPn = 49.3 kN; interaction ratio 0.848 (Eq. 11.3a) | λ = 3000/14.5 = 207 → Fe = 47.4 MPa → Fcr = 0.877·47.4 MPa → φPn = 49.4 kN | Exact |
| L 50×50×5 diagonal (L = 1803 mm) | φcPn = 22.3 kN; elastic lateral–torsional buckling in flexure | Imin (principal) = 45,100 mm⁴, r = 9.69 mm → λ = 186 → φPn = 22.3 kN | Exact |
| CHS 88.9×4 diagonal | Mn = 6.79 kNm (yielding); φcPn = 190.0 kN | Mp = Fy·Z = 0.235·28,900; λ = 60 → φPn = 190 kN | Exact |
| RHS 80×80×4 diagonal | Mn = 8.15 kNm | Z (derived) = (80·80² − 72·72²)/4 = 34,688 mm³ → Mp = 8.15 kNm | Exact |
| UPE 120 top chord (Lb = 1068 mm > Lp = 989 mm) | Mn = 16.40 kNm, inelastic lateral–torsional buckling; Lr = 5207 mm | Mp = 16.52 kNm; Mn < Mp because Lb slightly exceeds Lp | Consistent |
| Truss posts (IPE 80, 27 members) | φcPn = 86–155 kN depending on the post length; for posts in tension the tension ratio and the tension–flexure interaction were calculated | φtTn = 0.9·235·764 = 161.6 kN | Exact |
7. Torsional constant and modulus of elasticity in the finite element model
In the same truss and purlin model (280 nodes, 342 members), the torsional constants entering the finite element model were compared with the catalogue values:
| Section (FEM member) | FEM J (m⁴) | Expected | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| IPE 80 post | 7.0·10⁻⁹ | Catalogue 0.70 cm⁴ | Exact |
| HE 100 A post | 5.24·10⁻⁸ | Catalogue 5.24 cm⁴ | Exact |
| HE 120 A top chord | 5.99·10⁻⁸ | Catalogue 5.99 cm⁴ | Exact |
| IPE 120 purlin | 1.74·10⁻⁸ | Catalogue 1.74 cm⁴ | Exact |
| L 50×50×5 diagonal (no J in the catalogue) | 3.96·10⁻⁹ | (h + b − t)·t³/3 = 0.396 cm⁴ | Exact |
| RHS 80×80×4 diagonal (no J in the catalogue) | 1.7559·10⁻⁶ | Bredt: 2t(h − t)²(b − t)²/((h − t) + (b − t)) = 175.59 cm⁴ | Exact |
| CHS 88.9×4 diagonal | 1.93·10⁻⁶ | Catalogue 193 cm⁴ | Exact |
- For the RHS 80×80×4 section assigned to a reinforced concrete beam, J = 1.7559·10⁻⁶ m⁴ (Bredt, identical to the catalogue) is also used. The Saint-Venant approximation J = A⁴/(4π²(I₂ + I₃)) for polygon sections is exact for a circle; for a solid square section it differs from the exact value by about 8%.
- With the material card of this model (2.1×10⁶ kg/cm²), the steel modulus of elasticity in the finite element model was verified as E = 2.0601·10⁸ kN/m² (206,010 MPa).
- When the project is saved as .sy4 and .sbd and reopened, all section J values and E remain the same; when an old file without a J record is opened, J is derived from the steel catalogue.
8. Pipe, box and angle: verification against the code and the Application Guide
The design wall thickness of pipe and box sections (ÇYTHYE 5.4.2: 0.93·t for electric resistance welded members) and the geometric-axis bending of an equal-leg angle (ÇYTHYE 9.10.2(2)(i): the yield moment is 0.80 times the yield moment about the geometric axis) have been verified against the ÇYTHYE text (Official Gazette 15.02.2018, no. 30333) and the worked examples of the Ministry's ÇYTHYE Application Guide (2017):
| Check | Reference | StatiCAD | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guide Example 9.8 — box 200×200×8 (ERW, S275), Mn | 110.0 kNm (Wp = 400 cm³) | 109.99 kNm (Wp = 400.0 cm³) | 0.0% |
| Guide Example 9.10 — pipe 219.1×10 (S275), Mn | 112.75 kNm (Wp = 410 cm³) | 112.64 kNm (Wp = 409.6 cm³) | −0.1% |
| Guide Example 9.15 — L 160×160×14, Lb = 7 m, Cb = 1.14, Mn | 27.16 kNm (see note) | 25.37 kNm | Note |
| L 100×100×10, Lb = 2 m, φMnx (geometric axis) | 6.16 kNm (hand calculation with ÇYTHYE 9.10) | 6.163 kNm | 0.0% |
Guide Example 9.15 contains an arithmetic error: the leading factor of Eq. 9.69a is 0.58·200000·160⁴·14·1.14/7000² = 24.76 kNm and the root term is √(1 + 0.88·(7000·14/160²)²) = 3.728; the correct result is Mcr = 24.76·(3.728 − 1) = 67.55 kNm. The Guide gives 92.31 kNm (= 24.76·3.728; the “−1” was forgotten); with the same leading factor, Example 9.14 (9.69b, “+1”) 117.06 = 24.76·4.728 is correct. With the correct Mcr, Mn = (1.92 − 1.17·√(19.69/67.55))·19.69 = 25.37 kNm, which is identical to the program result. 0.80·My = 19.69 kNm is identical to the Guide.
9. TBDY Table 9.3 section compactness requirement
With E = 200,000 MPa, Fy = 235 MPa. Hand-calculated limits: flange 8.75 / 11.09; box 16.05 / 32.67; pipe 32.34 / 59.57; web (Ca = 0) 71.47.
| Section | Level | Ratio (program) | Limit (program) | Hand calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HEA200 | High | bf/2tf = 10.00 | 8.75 | 200/(2·10) = 10.0 | Not satisfied |
| HEA200 | Limited | 10.00 | 11.09 | — | Satisfied |
| HEA300 | High | 10.71 | 8.75 | 300/(2·14) = 10.71 | Not satisfied |
| IPE300, N = 600 kN | High | h/tw = 35.01 | 53.97 | Ca = 600,000/(0.9·235·5381) = 0.527; 0.77·29.17·(2.93 − 0.527) = 53.97 | Satisfied |
| RHS 200×200×8 | High | b/t = 23.88 | 16.05 | td = 7.44: (200 − 22.32)/7.44 = 23.88 | Not satisfied |
| RHS 200×200×8 | Limited | 23.88 | 32.67 | — | Satisfied |
| CHS 168.3×5 | High | D/t = 36.19 | 32.34 | 168.3/4.65 = 36.19 | Not satisfied |
| L100×100×10 | High | b/t = 10.00 | 8.75 | 100/10 | Not satisfied |
In the two-storey frame model (C11 and C31), bf/2tf = 5.85 and h/tw = 20.72 were found for the IPE A 100 beams, and 4.82 / 18.2 for the IPE 100 columns. In the beams, Lb = 6000 mm exceeds the Lb,max values (491 / 971 mm), so a lateral bracing warning was given. The report line appears on the beam and column pages.
10. Axial force amplified by D (9.3.1.3(b))
Model: 2-storey IPE 100 frame (S275 columns), system code C11 (DX = DY = 3), shear and vertical load method as finite elements. In the hand calculation, the largest compression and tension were found by scanning all of the combinations 1.2G + 1.0Q + 0.2S ± D(EX ± 0.3EY), ± D(0.3EX ± EY) and 0.9G ± D·E (including the eccentricity loadings) from the load case axial forces at the two ends of each column. In 12 of 12 columns the program value is identical to the hand calculation (compression; tension is 0 in every column).
| Column | EX axial force (kN, bottom end) | Program Nu (kN) | Hand calculation Nu (kN) | Nu/φPn | 9.12 base | Governing combination |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DHB01 | −0.069 | 1.664 | 1.664 | 0.059 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S-X1-0.3*Y1 |
| DHB02 | 0.002 | 2.152 | 2.152 | 0.076 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S+0.3*X1-Y1 |
| DHB03 | 0.051 | 1.840 | 1.840 | 0.065 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S+0.3*X1-Y1 |
| DHB04 | −0.069 | 1.664 | 1.664 | 0.059 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S-X1+0.3*Y1 |
| DHB05 | 0.002 | 2.152 | 2.152 | 0.076 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S+0.3*X1+Y1 |
| DHB06 | 0.051 | 1.840 | 1.840 | 0.065 | Yes | G+nQ+0.2*S+0.3*X1+Y1 |
| DHZ01 | −0.030 | 0.735 | 0.735 | 0.026 | No | G+nQ+0.2*S-X1-0.3*Y1 |
| DHZ02 | 0.001 | 0.976 | 0.976 | 0.034 | No | G+nQ+0.2*S+0.3*X1-Y1 |
Since the seismic axial force is small in this model, the check is satisfied. The column pages of the report contain the “TBDY 9.3.1.3(b)” line, and for columns connected to the foundation also the “TBDY 9.12” line (Mp = 1.1·1.3·275·Zy; for IPE 100, Zy = 39.41 cm³ → 15.50 kNm).
11. Strong column and joint checks (9.3.2, 9.3.4)
Model: 2-storey frame with 3×2 columns and 6 m spans (column IPE 100, S275; beam IPE A 100, Fy = 440 MPa, Ry = 1.25), C11. Hand calculation for the storey 1 corner column DHB01:
| Quantity | Hand calculation | Program |
|---|---|---|
| Mpr = 1.1·1.25·440·Wp (IPE A 100, ≈33.0 cm³) | 19.96 kNm | 19.96 |
| ℓn = 6000 − 2·100/2 | 5900 mm | 5900 |
| Vuc = 0.24 + 2·19.96/5.90 | 7.01 kN | 7.01 |
| ΣM*pc (M3) = 39.41·(275 − P/A)·2 columns | 21.6 kNm | 21.58 |
| ΣM*pb (M3) = 19.96 + 7.01·0.100/2 | 20.31 kNm | 20.32 |
| Ratio M3 / M2 (Wpz = 9.15 cm³; Muv = Vuc·55/2) | 1.06 / 0.25 | 1.06 / 0.25 → Inadequate |
| Vup = 19.96/(98 − 4.7) − 19.96/3.0 | 207.3 kN | 207.3 |
| φRn = 0.6·275·(100·4.1 + 3·55·5.7²/98) | 76.7 kN | 76.7 (ratio 2.70; td = 7.9 mm) |
| Continuity: 0.4·√(1.8·55·4.7·1.25·440/(1.3·275)) ; 55/6 | 10.7 ; 9.2 mm > tcf = 5.7 | Required, t ≥ 4.7 mm |
| Lateral bracing: 0.02·440·55·4.7 | 2.27 kN | 2.27 |
In the middle columns (two X beams) the ratio is 0.53 and Vup = 414.7 kN (two beams). The upper storey columns are exempt under 9.3.3.1(a) because they are top-storey columns and Pu < 0.3·Fy·Ag is satisfied. The model was deliberately chosen weak (IPE 100 column, 440 MPa beam): the “Inadequate” result and the related warnings were also tested.
12. Concentric brace members (9.6)
In the same frame, system C13 (high ductility level concentrically braced, D = 2). On the y = 300 axis of storey 1 an X pair (RHS100×100×5) and an inverted V pair (RHS80×80×4, apex at the middle of HB02); on the x = 300 axis of storey 1 a single diagonal (RHS80×80×3); in storey 2 a pair connected to the middle of the column (RHS100×100×5); S275, ends hinged. It was first tested that the inclined brace is connected to two storey joints: it carries axial force under EX and its moment is zero.
| Brace | Layout (program) | KL/i | Fcre (MPa) | P1 (kN) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HB11/HB12 | X | 6708/38.6 = 174 ≤ 200 | 57.3 | 112.3 | Table 9.3: b/t 18.5 > 14.8 → Inadequate |
| HB13/HB14 | Inverted V (beam HB02) | 4243/30.9 = 137 | 91.7 | 114.9 | Table 9.3 → Inadequate |
| HB15 | Diagonal | 6708/31.3 = 214 > 200 | 37.8 | 36.2 | Inadequate; axis share 0% (single brace) → 9.6.1.2 warning |
| HZ11/HZ12 | K | 160 | 67.4 | 132.1 | K layout → Inadequate |
Hand calculation (HB11): KL/i = 6708/38.6 = 173.8; Fe = π²·200000/173.8² = 65.3 MPa; Ry·Fy/Fe = 1.4·275/65.3 = 5.9 > 2.25 → Fcre = 0.877·65.3 = 57.3 MPa; P1 = 1.14·57.3·1718 = 112.3 kN; T = 1.4·275·1718 = 661.4 kN; 9.6.6 compression = 1.1·112.3 = 123.5 kN; Ae,req = 661.4/(1.3·0.430) = 1183 mm². The results are identical to the program. In the X and inverted V pairs on the y = 300 axis the compression share is 46% (acceptable). The brace flag is preserved when the project is saved and reopened. The report beam pages contain the “TBDY 9.6” lines. That tube braces need a thick wall in Table 9.3 is a code requirement (the b/t limit is 0.55·√(E/Fy) for a high ductility brace).
13. Columns and beams of the braced frame (9.6.2 / 9.7.2)
The same model was solved first with C13 (high) and then with C32 (limited). Since the seismic forces in the model are small (brace D·E axial force 1–5 kN), the mechanism share in the columns was limited by D·E (9.6.2.4) and the column design force came out equal to D·E; the mechanism share itself was verified by hand:
| Member | Program | Hand calculation |
|---|---|---|
| DHB01 (300, 300) mechanism compression | 295.8 kN | HB12 upper end: T·sin θ = 661.4·300/√(600² + 300²) = 295.8 |
| DHB02 (900, 300) mechanism compression | 433.2 kN | HB11 upper end 295.8 + HB02 V beam end ½·274.9 = 433.3 |
| HB02 inverted V unbalanced force (high, mechanism b) | Fz = 274.9 kN, Fh = 323.7 kN | (T − P2)·sin 45° = (423.3 − 34.5)·0.707 = 274.9; (T + P2)·0.707 = 323.7 |
| HB02 moment / shear without braces | 412.74 kNm / 137.7 kN | PL/4 = 274.9·6/4 = 412.3 + self-weight 0.4; P/2 = 137.5 + 0.2 |
| HB02 limited (C32) | Fz = −19.4 kN (upward) | Tension min(T; D·E) = 2.8 kN, compression 0.3·Fcr·Ag ≈ 30.2 kN: (2.8 − 30.2)·0.707 = −19.4 |
HB02 (IPE A 100) with the unbalanced force gives a ratio of 119 → Inadequate (the beam is far too small for this brace; the expected result). The braced-axis beams HB01, HB05, HB06 and HZ05 are adequate with the D·E envelope. The column and beam pages of the report contain the “TBDY 9.6.2.2–9.6.2.4”, “TBDY 9.6.2.4” and “9.6.4.1(c)” lines.
Case where the mechanism share remains smaller than D·E: To the same model, a 30 t weightless seismic mass was added on top of 8 columns on both storeys (C13). The brace D·E axial forces rise to 70–384 kN (384 kN > T = 324 kN in HB15). If the mechanism and the elastic D·E column axial shares have opposite signs, or if no brace transfers force to the column in that direction, D·E is used:
| Column | Mechanism (unlimited) comp./tens. | Design N comp./tens. | D·E N comp./tens. | Governing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DHB04 | 192.4 / 192.4 | 147.7 / 65.5 | 210.0 / 205.1 | Mechanism in compression: HB15 in tension under +Y, T·sin θ = 324.0·0.447 = 144.9 + vertical 2.8 = 147.7 < 210 |
| DHB01 | 295.8 / 50.2 | 69.8 / 49.0 | 69.8 / 66.9 | D·E limit in compression (295.8 > 69.8); mechanism in tension: P1·sin θ = 112.3·0.447 = 50.2 − vertical 1.2 |
| DHB02 | 433.2 / 0 | 71.3 / 67.8 | 71.3 / 67.8 | D·E limit in compression; no brace force on the column in the tension direction → D·E |
| DHB05, DHZ04, DHZ05 | 160–192 | = D·E | K pair joint: in the mechanism T ≫ P1, in the elastic solution the vertical components cancel each other → opposite signs → D·E |
Axial force of a bay beam with a brace (9.6.2.4): In the same model (C13, D = 2), braces working in tension, whose T is far above the D·E force, are connected to HB01, HB02, HB05 and HZ05: r = 1, the axial force is the same as D·E. Only HB15 (RHS80×80×3, T = 324.0 kN) is connected to HB06: in the combination 0.9G − 0.3X1 + Y1, FDE = 2·(−184.32) − 0.6·(−25.5) = −353.3 kN (tension) → r = 324.0/353.3 = 0.917 (program 0.917); beam N = 0.9·(−1.46) + 0.917·(2·8.06 − 0.6·(−2.08)) = 14.6 kN (program 14.6; D·E envelope 19.1 kN). The results for limited ductility level (C32) do not change.
14. Brace–beam–column connection (9.6.5)
Same model, C13. Beam IPE A 100 (recorded Fy = 440 MPa, Wpl = 33.0 cm³, Ry = 1.25), column IPE 100 (S275, Ry = 1.3, Wpl,y = 39.4; Wpl,z = 9.15 cm³).
| Beam / end | Program | Hand calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Beam 1.1·Ry·Mp | 19.97 kNm | 1.1·1.25·440·33,000 = 19.97 |
| HB01 left (two columns, strong axis) | ΣMp 31.00 → M = 19.97 kNm | 2·1.1·1.3·275·39,410 = 31.00; min = 19.97 |
| HB06 left (two columns, weak axis) | 7.20 kNm | 2·1.1·1.3·275·9,150 = 7.20 |
| HZ05 left (lower column only, top storey) | 15.50 kNm | 1.1·1.3·275·39,410 = 15.50 |
| Beam hinged at both ends | Hinged → 0.025 rad (Annex 9C) | — |
The right end of HB02, where the inverted V braces connect in the span, is correctly not flagged. The analysis warning and the “TBDY 9.6.5” lines appear in the report.
15. Diaphragm collector and horizontal brace (9.10.3 / 9.10.4)
Same model, C13. A brace (RHS80×80×4) in the slab plane was added on storey 1 in the 900–1500 × 300–900 bay. The program recognised it as a horizontal brace and did not include it in the concentric brace checks; the five beams connected to its ends became beams of the horizontal brace system, and on storey 2 the post HZ04 outside the braced bay on the axis of the K pair became the collector.
| Member | Fully rigid diaphragm | Semi-rigid diaphragm |
|---|---|---|
| HB16 horizontal brace, D·E N | 0.0 kN (ratio 0.13) | 28.5 kN (ratio 1.37, Inadequate) |
| HB04, D·E N | 19.5 kN | 119.7 kN |
| HZ04 collector, D·E N | 20.7 kN | 48.6 kN |
In the fully rigid diaphragm the axial force of the horizontal brace is zero and the program warns; this is the expected behaviour. The report contains the “TBDY 9.10.3 / 9.10.4” lines. Boundary: all beams connected to the horizontal brace joint (including those in adjacent bays) are covered (conservative).
16. Tension-only brace (9.7.4.3, 9.10.4)
Same model, C32 (limited ductility level, D = 2). The X pair HB11 / HB12 (RHS100×100×5) on storey 1 was first made normal braces and then tension-only braces.
| Quantity | Normal X | Tension-only X |
|---|---|---|
| EX axial force HB11 / HB12 (kN, + compression) | −114.8 / +119.1 | −84.5 / +86.7 (A/2: the axis share decreases) |
| Mode 2 period | 0.5038 s | 0.5067 s |
| Member check HB11 | Ratio 1.49 with compression buckling | Tu = 186.4 kN, 0.90·Fy·Ag = 425.2 kN, ratio 0.44 |
| KL/i limit, 9.7.5 compression | 200; 123.5 kN | 300; 0 |
| D·E tension HB11 | 257.5 kN | 373.6 kN |
Hand calculation (HB11, 0.9G + X1 + 0.3Y1): NE(HB11) = −84.52 − 0.3·33.21 = −94.48 kN; NE(HB12) = 86.72 + 0.3·20.07 = 92.74 kN; since the cos θ of the two braces is equal, f = (94.48 + 92.74)/94.48 = 1.982 (program 1.9815); Tu = 1.982·94.48 − 0.9·0.94 = 186.4 kN (program 186.38). When C13 is selected, the two braces become Inadequate under 9.6.4.3 and a warning is given; when HB12 is made a normal brace, HB11 becomes Inadequate with “no pair”. The flag is preserved when the project is saved and reopened, and the results are identical.
Horizontal tension-only brace (C32, semi-rigid diaphragm): HB17 (900,900 → 1500,300; RHS80×80×4), crossing HB16 (900,300 → 1500,900), was added.
| Case | HB16 | HB17 |
|---|---|---|
| Normal X (9.10.4 D·E, with compression buckling) | Ncomp 47.1 kN, ratio 2.19 (Inadequate) | Ncomp 36.1 kN, ratio 1.70 |
| Tension-only X | Tu = 55.35 kN (D·E), f = 1.311, ratio 0.35 | Tu = 55.35 kN, f = 4.217, ratio 0.35 |
| HB17 normal, HB16 alone tension-only | No pair → Inadequate | — |
Hand calculation (HB16, D = 2, EY + 0.3EX): NE,16 = 2·(−16.29) + 0.6·(−16.61) = −42.55 kN; NE,17 = 2·8.90 + 0.6·(−7.64) = 13.22 kN; since the weights are equal in a square bay, f = 55.77/42.55 = 1.311; Tu = 1.311·42.55 − 0.9·0.47 = 55.4 kN.
17. Diaphragm chord (9.10.2)
Same model, with three rectangular slabs (300–2100 × 300–900) on both storeys, C32, fully rigid diaphragm. The 1500–2100 bay is timber: since that edge is not steel, only HB06 at x = 300 was counted as a chord under the X earthquake; under the Y earthquake the steel HB01, HB02, HB04 and HB05 on the y = 300 and 900 axes are chords. The independent calculation was made with the same formula using the transfer forces given by the program (slab mass uniform).
| Storey / earthquake | F (kN) | Mmax program (kNm) | Mmax independent (kNm) | Closure (kNm) | T (kN) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 / X | 420.7 (column −11.8; brace 432.6) | 1236.4 | 1236.4 | 58.6 | 68.5 |
| 1 / Y | 418.8 (column 84.0; brace 334.8) | 1011.9 | 1011.7 | 56.5 | 167.9 |
| 2 / X | 173.4 | 137.6 | 136.8 | 42.7 | 7.6 |
| 2 / Y | 172.7 | 412.7 | 412.6 | 7.0 | 68.5 |
In the semi-rigid diaphragm the results agree within 1–2%.
18. Space roof truss (9.10.4)
Model: to the model of Section 17, a steel plane truss (HE 100 A chords, IPE 80 web members) was added at the x = 2100 axis on storey 2, and a steel hip roof over 300–1500 × 300–900. The members of the plane truss did not enter the check; the roof group was found to be three-dimensional: 62 steel beams (IPE 200 / 160 / 120, UPN 120) and 11 posts were checked with D·E, and 9 beams came out Inadequate (e.g. HZ49 IPE 200: Ncomp = 278.3 kN, M = 20.0 kNm, ratio 1.17). For the post DHZ12 (HE 100 A, S235) the D·E tension is 126.7 kN / (0.90·235·2124 = 449 kN) = 0.28 (program 0.28).
19. Evaluation
All quantities of the beam and column chain reflected in the report, including the checks of the truss and purlin members and the other section types, agree exactly with the hand calculations. The TBDY 2018 Chapter 9 requirements (section compactness, forces amplified by D, strong column, joint checks, concentric braces, diaphragm chord) have also been verified by hand calculation and independent calculation. Printing the intermediate quantities (Lp, Lr, Cb, KL/r, limit state, governing combination) next to the result in the report allows the engineer to check every result easily.
It is essential that all results produced by the software are checked by the responsible engineer.